Development
and Characterization of a Stable Suspension of Rifampicin
and Isoniazid
AM
Avachat1* and SB Bhise2
1Department of Pharmaceutics, Sinhgad
ovt.
ABSTRACT
Rifampicin (RMP)
and Isoniazid (INH) are highly unstable in liquid
dosage form and there is no liquid product available. A novel concept of
formulating a suspension of RMP and INH for pediatric and geriatric application
has been tried. The reconstitutable dry syrup which
can be reconstituted by using a special vehicle has shown very good stability
at 2-80C and at 250C for more than 1 month and 14 days
respectively using a stability indicating HPLC method. The in vitro dissolution
studies have revealed no adverse impact of special vehicle on dissolution. Thus
this combination product could prove to be a major boost for the market need
for pediatric patients.
KEYWORDS: Rifampicin, Isoniazid, suspension,
stability
1.0 INTRODUCTION
Tuberculosis is prevalent in adult as well
as in pediatric population. To treat tuberculosis effectively in children who
are less than 4 years of age, has various issues with respect to compliance due
to non availability of a proper suspension dosage form especially of
combination drugs.
Rifampicin (RMP) is a rifamycin
group of antibiotic with potential and established application against Mycobacterium tuberculosis. Isoniazid (INH) is a time tested and well established drug
for treatment of tuberculosis. The formulation containing both RMP and INH is
prudent for preventing the emergence of resistance for single drug. Though
there are a large number of alternatives for adults, for pediatric patients
only dispersible tablets are available. The dispersible tablets have multiple
draw backs like non-uniformity of dispersion, high dipersibility
time, formation of very coarse dispersion which settles very rapidly leading to
incomplete dose administration and poor palatability. It has been recommended
by WHO that FDC liquid formulations be made in small volumes for pediatric
patients which can be an alternative to the preferred capsules which are mixed
with food1 or FDC liquid
formulations in small volumes and with weight-based dispensers.
It is known that RMP undergoes very rapid
degradation in presence of INH under aqueous environment. This degradation is
so rapid that the product cannot have shelf life beyond one week. It has been
reported that INH triggers the degradation of RMP in acidic medium due to
formation of isonicotinyl hydrazone
and the degradation pathway
of RMP in presence of INH has also been proposed 2,3.
WHO has recommended that priority need is
for the development of fixed low dosage or breakable tablets. Preference should
be to develop combination liquid formulations, which are considered too
difficult to use (complexity of different drugs, lack of adequate dose
measurement, volume, storage, compliance, bad taste etc.), while powders are
considered impractical (texture, lack of pure water etc.).
Table
1: Formulation of Dry syrup
|
Sr.
No. |
Ingredients |
Quantity |
|
01. |
RMP |
150mg/5 ml |
|
02. |
INH |
75mg/5ml |
|
03. |
Xanthan Gum |
0.1% |
|
04. |
Sucrose (200#) |
40% |
|
05. |
Methyl and propyl paraben (9:1) |
0.2% |
|
06. |
Ascorbic acid |
0.25% |
|
07. |
Colloidal Silicon dioxide (Aerosil-200) |
1% |
|
08 |
Sodium Saccharine |
0.1% |
|
09 |
Dry Flavour ( |
1% |
The above formulation would be reconstituted either
with freshly boiled and cooled water or with Oil (MCT (3.8ml/5mL) + 0.1% tocopherol + 0.1%Tween 80)
Table 2: Formulation of Oil
based Suspension
|
Sr. No. |
Ingredients |
Quantity |
|
01. |
RMP |
150mg/5 ml |
|
02. |
INH |
75 mg/5ml |
|
03. |
Sucrose (200#) |
2gm/5mL |
|
04. |
Tocopherol (Vitamin-E) |
0.1% |
|
05 |
Tween-80 |
0.1% |
|
06 |
Sodium Saccharin |
0.1% |
|
07 |
Flavour orange (oil soluble) |
0.2% |
|
08 |
Medium chain Triglycerides (MCT) |
Q.S to make 100 ml |
It has been
reported that RMP in the presence of INH under aqueous conditions as a
suspension undergoes very rapid decomposition. This
study was reported for the suspension of RMP, INH and pyrazinamide
in which the formulations of the drugs alone and their combinations were stored
at 4, 24 and 40 °C for 28 days4.
The suspensions had a pH range between 4.05 and 6.10. Differential extents of
decomposition were observed between suspensions of single drugs and mixtures of
two and three drugs. Degradation, as high as 98% in the presence of INH has
been reported within 28 days.
With the above
background it was thought to develop RMP and INH product through different
alternatives of administering the drugs; as suspension. Different types of
suspension formulations were thought to be made like dry reconstitutable
suspension (constituted with oil/water as vehicle) and ready to use oil based
suspension which would be made with a view to minimize the degradation of RMP
in a combined dosage form with INH. Simple formulations were thought to be made
in each category. These would be then evaluated for various physicochemical
properties and more importantly stability studies.
2.0 EXPERIMENTAL:
2.1 Materials:
RMP (USP), INH (IP) and known degradation products of
RMP were gifted by Lupin Ltd,
2.2 Formulation of RMP and
INH suspensions:
Three different types of suspension formulations [Dry
(reconstituted with oil/water) and oil based] were made with a view to minimize
the degradation of rifampicin in combined dosage
forms. The dry syrup formulation would be reconstituted either with freshly
boiled and cooled water or with Oil [Medium chain triglycerides (MCT)+ tocopherol (Vitamin E) + Tween
80] at the time of administration. Tween 80 would
ensure proper wetting of the hydrophobic drug, RMP and would also ensure
dissolution in the GI media.
The formulae of dry and oily formulations are given in
Tables 1and 2. These formulations were made to ascertain that in which type of
formulations this drug combination is more stable. For the preparation of ‘dry
syrup’ all ingredients were taken in geometric proportions in a mortar pestle
and were lightly triturated and this blend was then filled in bottles.
For the ‘ready to use oily suspension’, weighed
quantity of RMP was taken in a beaker. Sucrose was very finely triturated
(passed through 200#) along with sodium saccharin. To it INH was added with
light trituration and was then mixed with the
above. Tween
80 and tocopherol were dissolved in MCT (Oil) and
added to the prepared dry mixture with stirring using a mechanical stirrer.
Finally flavor was added to this suspension.
Table 3: Sedimentation Volume
(S.V.R.) of reconstituted suspension
|
Sr.
No. |
Time
(days) |
S.V.R. |
|
|
Oily |
Aqueous |
||
|
1 |
0 |
1 |
1 |
|
2 |
4 |
0.62 |
0.91 |
|
3 |
8 |
0.45 |
0.85 |
|
4 |
12 |
0.42 |
0.84 |
|
5 |
14 |
0.41 |
0.81 |
Table No 4: Flow properties of
dry suspension
|
Sr. No. |
Parameters |
Values |
|
01. |
Bulk Density( g/cc) |
0.55 |
|
02. |
Tapped Density (g/cc) |
0.70 |
|
03. |
Carr’s Index (%) |
21.42 |
|
04. |
Angle of repose (0) |
32 |
Table 5: Assay of RMP
|
Time/condition |
Oily
Suspension |
Dry
Syrup |
||
|
|
RMP |
INH |
RMP |
INH |
|
0 day |
100.4 |
99.71 |
99.89 |
99.81 |
|
1 month 400C/75%RH |
--- |
--- |
97.02 |
98.51 |
|
3 months 400C/75%RH |
--- |
--- |
96.41 |
97.41 |
|
1 month 2-80C |
97.60 |
98.21 |
---- |
---- |
|
3months 300C/65%RH |
93.31 |
96.52 |
98.52 |
98.11 |
- INH ready to use oily suspension and dry syrup
2.3 Evaluation of suspensions:
The dry syrups were analysed
as such in the dry form for all powder characteristics including flow
properties and densities. The bulk density (B.D), tapped density (T.D), Carr’s
index (TD-B.D/TD× 100) and angle of repose (θ= tan-1 b/h) was
determined for dry suspension formulations by the standard methods. The
reconstituted formulations/ oily suspension were analyzed for sedimentation
rate and were also subjected to dissolution studies. The sedimentation rate was
observed for 14 days (after reconstitution) by using the formula as given
below:
F
= Vu/Vo
Where F= sedimentation rate
Vu=Volume of sediment at time ‘t’
Vo= Volume of sediment at time ‘t=0’
2.4 Drug content for RMP/INH
suspension and RBN/INH suspension:
Assay of the all the three types of suspensions was
performed on zero day for dry syrup and for the reconstituted suspension/s
using HPLC (Shimadzu) for both RMP and INH as per USP5.
Table 6: Assay of RMP- INH
reconstituted dry syrup
|
Time/condition |
Aqueous based
reconstituted Suspension |
Oil based reconstituted
suspension |
||
|
|
RMP |
INH |
RMP |
INH |
|
0 day |
98.51 |
98.01 |
99.53 |
98.64 |
|
7 days (2-80C) |
81.23 |
90.41 |
99.31 |
98.11 |
|
14 days (2-80C) |
61.53 |
86.21 |
98.62 |
97.23 |
|
7 days RT |
--- |
--- |
98.68 |
98.53 |
|
14 days RT |
--- |
--- |
98.51 |
97.89 |
2.5 Stability testing:
2.5.1 Accelerated stability
testing for drug content and other parameters:
The dry syrup and the oil based suspensions were
subjected to accelerated stability testing. The dry syrups were placed at 300C/65%
RH and 400C and 75% RH and tested for all parameters as described in
section 2.3 up to three months (1 and 3 months). After reconstitution
(Oil/water) the suspensions were kept for 14 days in refrigerator and at room
temperature and checked for assay. The drug content was determined and
stability was also checked during the accelerated stability testing period in
the dry form as well as after reconstitution (14 days) by HPLC as per USP.
2.6 Dissolution of suspensions:
Based on the stability and assay of the suspensions it
was observed that dry syrup, reconstituted with oil had maximum stability for
the RMP/INH combination. Only this suspension was subjected to dissolution
studies.
2.6.1 Dissolution Conditions:
Media:
0.1N HCl , 900 mL, RPM: 50, Time Point: 10, 20, 30,
45 Mins. Temp: 37±0.5şC
Apparatus: USP Type II (Paddle) Electrolab
2.6.2 Standard Preparation:
150 mg RMP and 75 mg of INH along with 5 mL diluent was diluted to 100 mL with methanol. This solution was then suitably diluted
further with methanol to get a final concentration of 50 mcg/mL.
2.6.3 Test Preparation:
Suspension equivalent to 150 mg RMP (166.66 µg/mL) and 75 mg INH (83.33 µg/mL)
was added in 900 ml dissolution media, volume withdrawn at each sampling point
was 10 mL. 3 mL of this
sample was diluted up to 10 mL with methanol to get
final concentration of 50 µg/mL.
3.0 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION:
3.1 Formulation of suspensions:
Although most common, reconstitutable
suspension dosage form uses water as a vehicle, but reconstitution with oil
also can be an alternative for drugs with poor aqueous stability. For
ciprofloxacin suspension (dry syrup) available in the
Figure1:
Dissolution of Rifampicin and Isoniazid
from reconstituted oily suspension
Two kinds of suspension formulations of RMP and INH
combination were prepared as per formula shown in Table 1 and 2 by a very
simple procedure. The oily and dry formulations were made to determine the
maximum stability of RMP and INH combination. Since RMP is prone to oxidation,
antioxidants were added in each formulation6.
The choice of antioxidants was made according to the nature of formulations. Tocopherol (Vitamin E) was added as an antioxidant in oil
based suspension/oil used for reconstitution of dry syrup because it is oil
miscible and hence can provide more effective protection of drug as well as
fatty acids presents in oily vehicle. Ascorbic acid was the antioxidant of
choice for dry as well as reconstituted aqueous suspension because it can act
by different mechanisms namely preferential oxidation as well as can bring
about reduction. As well as it is water soluble so it can provide effective
protection even after reconstitution of the suspension. In case of dry
suspension, methyl and propyl paraben
were added as preservatives because this formulation contained a natural gum
which is prone to microbial degradation. Formulations containing antimicrobial
agents are generally devoid of preservative but since rifamycin
class of antibiotics are active against a selective class of microbes so a need
was felt to add anti microbial preservatives in this formulation.
3.2 Evaluation of suspension:
The prepared formulations were evaluated for
sedimentation volume and the result for the same is shown in Table 3. For the
dry suspension the flow related properties of the dry powder were also
evaluated and their results are shown in table 4.
The sedimentation volume results show that the
sedimentation rate for suspension was slow and the cake if any was easily redispersible. The dry syrup reconstituted with water
settled slowly as compared to the one which was reconstituted with oil. However
due to the presence of aerosil there was no hard cake
formation. The result of flow property of dry suspension reveals adequate flow
characters for the dry powder for suspension.
3.3 Drug content analysis by
HPLC:
The results of assay for RMP and INH (based on HPLC) on
zero day for all products as well as after storage under various conditions is
listed in table 5 and 6.
The dry syrup was reconstituted using water and in the
second study it was reconstituted with oil. Both the reconstituted products
were stored at 2-80C under refrigeration, while the product which
was reconstituted with oil was also kept at room temperature to study the assay
of RMP and INH. The data is depicted in table 6. All the assays were carried
out using HPLC method as per USP.
3.4 Dissolution of reconstituted suspension (oil based):
As it is reported in literature that fat
reduces the absorption of RMP7
it was thought necessary to carry out the dissolution of the oil based reconstitutable suspension to check that whether there is
any problem with the dissolution of RMP or INH (table 7, figure1). The drug
content was determined by HPLC as per USP. The dissolution studies revealed that the oil based product shows rapid
and complete dissolution of RMP and INH clearly indicating that the oily
vehicle has not impacted the dissolution adversely. This could be because of
the use of surfactant, namely tween 80 and presence
of hydrophilic components like sugar.
4.0 CONCLUSION:
Based on the stability data
following conclusions can be drawn
1.
Readymade suspension of combination drug even using
oily vehicle may not be feasible option for long term stability.
2.
Dry syrup which can be reconstituted with oil (MCT
oil) would be best option for having a uniform stable product for pediatric
administration
3.
Based on the stability data of reconstituted product
it could be concluded that if the reconstituted product is stored at 2-80c
then it can be used minimum up to one month
whereas if it is stored at room temperature it can be consumed minimum
up to 14 days.
4.
The dissolution studies revealed that the oil based
product shows rapid and complete dissolution of both the drugs.
5.
The sedimentation volume study revealed that
reconstituted suspension does not have caking tendency and are easily redispersed.
5.0 REFERENCES:
1.
Fixed‐Dose Combinations for HIV
/ AIDS, tuberculosis and malaria, report of a meeting
held from 16‐18 December 2003, World Health
Organisation,
2.
Shishoo CJ et al. Stability of rifampicin in
dissolution medium in presence of isoniazid, Int. J. Pharm. 1999; 190:
109-123.
3.
Singh S
et al. The reason for an increase in decomposition
of rifampicin in the presence of isoniazid
under acid conditions, Pharm. Pharmacol. Commun. 2000a; 6: 405-410.
4. Seifart
HI, Parkin DP and Donald PR. Stability of Isoniazid, Rifampicin and Pyrazinamide in suspensions used for the treatment of
tuberculosis in children, Pediatr. Infect. Dis. 1991;
10: 827–831.
5.
USP
27-NF 22, The United States Pharmacopoeial
Convention,
6.
Singh S et al,
Behaviour of uptake of moisture by drugs and excipients under accelerated
conditions of temperature and humidity in the absence and the presence of
light. 1. Pure anti-tuberculosis drugs and their combinations. Int. J. Pharm.
2002; 245: 37– 44.
7.
.
Received on 08.09.2009
Accepted on 15.10.2009
© A&V Publication all right reserved
Research Journal of Pharmaceutical Dosage
Forms and Technology. 1(3): Nov. – Dec. 2009, 05-12